Gaza ceasefire faces collapse as Israel, Hamas miss key commitments
A ceasefire between Israel and Hamas that began in October 2025 is showing severe signs of strain, with both parties failing to meet their basic commitments. Trump's US-led Board of Peace warned this week that the agreement is on the brink of collapse without immediate action. Since the ceasefire took effect, over 1,600 Palestinians and five Israeli soldiers have been killed. The core issues blocking progress are Hamas disarmament, Israeli withdrawal, and deployment of an international security force. Israel controls roughly 60 percent of Gaza, more than the 50-53 percent outlined in the original deal, while hundreds of thousands of Palestinians remain in temporary shelters. Both sides accuse the other of violating the agreement, as negotiations stall over sequencing—who disarms or withdraws first. Without major recommitment from both parties, mediators warn the fragile peace could collapse entirely.
Key facts
- Ceasefire between Israel and Hamas began October 2025, now 13 months in effect
- Over 1,600 Palestinians and 5 Israeli soldiers killed since ceasefire took effect
- Israel controls approximately 60 percent of Gaza, expanded from 50-53 percent at ceasefire start
- Board of Peace warned on November 18, 2026 ceasefire faces imminent collapse without action
- More than 150,000 tents remain outside Gaza awaiting delivery
- Three core obstacles: Hamas disarmament, Israeli withdrawal, international security force deployment
How different outlets framed it
Left-leaning coverage: Left-leaning outlets stress ongoing Israeli military operations, inadequate humanitarian aid delivery, and Palestinian suffering under occupation. They highlight UN findings of potential genocidal conduct and question whether international oversight mechanisms have real enforcement power. Sources point to Israeli control expanding beyond agreed boundaries and the humanitarian catastrophe of Palestinians facing 'another winter in tents and rubble.'
Right-leaning coverage: Right-leaning and Israeli security-focused commentary emphasizes the existential threat Hamas poses and the necessity of verifiable disarmament before Israeli withdrawal. They stress Hamas's historical rearmament capacity, the Oct. 7 precedent, and argue that Israel cannot risk security by pulling back before genuine Hamas disarmament is confirmed. Sources cite Israeli officials' concerns about Hamas infrastructure rebuilding and the need for 'credible threats' to enforce agreements.
Limits of this briefing
Coverage is limited by ongoing negotiations not yet public, and both sides dispute casualty figures. The humanitarian impact figures vary between Israeli military, Palestinian health officials, and international monitors. Some political perspectives from regional actors like Egypt, Qatar, and Turkey appear less prominently in English-language media than Western outlets.
Sources
- Al Jazeera: Board of Peace warns Gaza ceasefire faces imminent collapse without action Left
- Bloomberg: Trump's Board of Peace Warns Gaza Ceasefire Could Collapse Centre
- Democracy Now!: Israel Failed to Meet Commitments to Deliver Food and Supplies to Gaza Left
- Washington Institute for Near East Policy: One Year After the Gaza Ceasefire (Part 5): The View from Jerusalem Right
- Crisis Group: Hollow Promises: Resetting Gaza's Ceasefire Centre