Gaza ceasefire stalls as phase two negotiations face disarmament deadlock
A US-backed ceasefire between Israel and Hamas that began in October 2025 has entered phase two, which aims to establish an international stabilization force and transition Gaza's governance. However, talks have stalled over key disagreements. Hamas demands Israel fulfill military withdrawal commitments before disarming, while Israel and the Board of Peace call for disarmament first. Since the ceasefire took effect, Israeli military control has expanded to approximately 65 percent of Gaza, with reports of continued airstrikes and humanitarian access restrictions. Meanwhile, the UN-backed National Committee for the Administration of Gaza was established in January 2026 to oversee civilian governance during reconstruction, though implementation challenges persist on both sides.
Key facts
- Ceasefire between Israel and Hamas began October 10, 2025, based on Trump's US-backed peace plan
- Phase two negotiations focus on Hamas disarmament, Israeli military withdrawal, and international stabilization force deployment
- Israeli military control expanded from approximately 53 percent to 65 percent of Gaza by October 2026
- At least 1,400 Palestinians and 5 Israeli military personnel killed since ceasefire took effect
- National Committee for the Administration of Gaza established January 14-16, 2026, to govern civilian services
- Agreement on Hamas disarmament contingent on Israeli military withdrawal was reached July 31, 2026, but implementation stalled
- Only 66,607 of 189,000 planned aid trucks entered Gaza from October 2025 to August 2026
How different outlets framed it
Left-leaning coverage: Left-leaning outlets highlight ceasefire violations and Israeli expansion of territory control, citing UN reports of ongoing genocide and Palestinian civilian harm. The Intercept and New Arab focus on how Israel has expanded military control beyond the agreed-upon 53 percent to 65 percent, with continued airstrikes killing 1,400 Palestinians since October 2025. These sources emphasize that Israel is not honoring phase one commitments while demanding Hamas disarm.
Right-leaning coverage: Right-leaning sources including Long War Journal and Israeli media emphasize Hamas's reluctance to disarm and present Israeli security concerns as paramount. These outlets highlight Hamas's insistence on Israeli withdrawal before disarmament as obstructionist and stress Israel's legitimate security needs in Gaza. Israeli government statements emphasize Hamas's exploitation of civilian infrastructure and frame disarmament as essential before any further Israeli withdrawal.
Limits of this briefing
Coverage reflects significant disagreement between Israeli government claims and international organization reports regarding ceasefire violations and aid delivery. Access to Gaza remains restricted, limiting independent verification of some claims from each side.
Sources
- The Intercept: Palestinians Are Trapped Between War and Peace With 'Ceasefire' Left
- CNN: US and Hamas hold first direct talks since Gaza truce as ceasefire process stalls Centre
- Council on Foreign Relations: A Guide to the Gaza Peace Deal Centre
- FDD's Long War Journal: Gaza peace plan sees slow progress after Hamas meets in Cairo Right
- Times of Israel: Nov. 10: Under criticism, PM's office insists winter supplies entering Gaza Right