ASEAN, China fail to finalize South China Sea code after two decades of talks
China and Southeast Asian nations have reached a critical juncture in their disputed South China Sea waters. After more than twenty years of negotiations, the ASEAN and Chinese leadership met this week in Manila but failed to conclude a code of conduct governing maritime behavior in the region. They did agree on roughly eighty percent of the draft agreement, but three major issues remain unresolved: the geographic scope the pact should cover, how certain terms will be defined, and whether the accord should be legally binding. The South China Sea is one of the world's busiest shipping lanes, handling over five trillion dollars in annual trade and passing between five and seven hundred billion dollars in U.S. trade. China claims most of the waters based on a nine-dash line, overlapping with the territorial claims of four ASEAN members: the Philippines, Vietnam, Malaysia, and Brunei, plus Taiwan. The two countries and their maritime forces have engaged in numerous confrontations, with both sides accusing each other of dangerous actions. Negotiations will now continue when Singapore assumes ASEAN's rotating chairmanship next year.
Key facts
- ASEAN and China reached tentative agreement on approximately 80 percent of the code of conduct draft as of November 16, 2026
- China claims roughly 80 to 90 percent of the South China Sea based on its nine-dash line, overlapping with five nations' exclusive economic zones
- An international arbitration tribunal ruled in 2016 that China's historical claims lack basis under international law; China rejected the ruling
- The South China Sea carries more than five trillion dollars in annual maritime trade globally
- Negotiations have been ongoing for more than 20 years, with talks aimed at managing maritime incidents and preventing escalation
- Three unresolved issues include the agreement's geographic scope, definition of key terms, and whether it should be legally binding
- The Philippines and China have experienced numerous maritime confrontations involving coast guard vessels, water cannons, and ramming incidents
- Negotiations will resume when Singapore assumes ASEAN's rotating chairmanship in 2027
How different outlets framed it
Left-leaning coverage: Left-leaning outlets like Al Jazeera highlight Chinese military expansion and aggressive tactics, including water cannon attacks on Philippine vessels and the creation of artificial islands. They emphasize Southeast Asian nations' frustration that an international 2016 tribunal ruling invalidated Beijing's claims, yet China rejected that decision. Progressive analysis frames the dispute through the lens of international law, arguing smaller nations deserve protection and that China's actions threaten regional stability and global trade.
Right-leaning coverage: Right-leaning analysts and conservative outlets like The Epoch Times and Washington Times characterize China's actions as aggressive imperialism and expansionism threatening regional order. They emphasize military buildup on artificial islands, see Beijing's moves as part of a broader strategy to dominate Asia and displace U.S. influence, and call for stronger Western alliance-building and deterrence. These sources stress China's rejection of international law and advocate for more robust military support to allies like the Philippines.
Limits of this briefing
Coverage reflects perspectives primarily from Western, Southeast Asian, and international media sources. Direct statements from Chinese government sources are limited in these results, primarily appearing through Xinhua or via diplomatic messaging. The underlying strategic motivations, regional security perceptions, and long-term intentions of all parties remain subject to interpretation and ongoing debate among analysts.
Sources
- Al Jazeera: ASEAN, China fall short of agreeing on South China Sea code Left
- Associated Press / US News: China and Southeast Asia Pledge to Avoid Disputes During Talks on South China Sea Pact Centre
- East Asia Forum: Drifting through dispute in the South China Sea Centre
- The Epoch Times: China's Growing Military Presence Could Strain US Defenses in South China Sea: Analysts Right
- U.S. Department of State: U.S. Statement on Dangerous Chinese Actions in the South China Sea Right