ASEAN, China fail to finalize South China Sea code after 24 years
China and ASEAN have failed to conclude negotiations on a binding code of conduct for the South China Sea, despite reaching tentative agreement on about 80 percent of the draft. The two sides met in Manila this week but could not resolve four major outstanding issues: the legal status of the agreement, the geographic scope, definitions of sensitive terms, and whether the accord should be legally binding. This marks another delay in establishing clearer rules to prevent maritime incidents in the disputed region. Between January 2025 and May 2026, there were three collisions, 16 confrontations, 56 harassments, and 134 military movements involving maritime activity. The Philippines will hand off ASEAN's rotating chairmanship to Singapore, which will continue negotiations in 2027. China claims most of the South China Sea, overlapping with exclusive economic zones of Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, and Vietnam. The code aims to manage tensions and prevent escalation.
Key facts
- ASEAN and China agreed on approximately 80 percent of the code draft but missed their 2026 deadline
- Between January 2025 and May 2026, there were 3 collisions, 16 confrontations, 56 harassments, 134 military movements, and 176 military exercises in the South China Sea
- China claims nearly 90 percent of the South China Sea via its nine-dash line, conflicting with the exclusive economic zones of five nations
- A 2016 international arbitral ruling found China's claims had no legal basis under the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea
- Four major unresolved issues blocking the agreement: legal status, geographic scope, term definitions, and binding nature of the code
- Singapore will lead ASEAN negotiations continuing in 2027
How different outlets framed it
Left-leaning coverage: Left-leaning outlets emphasize China's assertive expansionism, militarization of artificial islands, and stalling tactics that work to Beijing's advantage by prolonging negotiations. They highlight how China ignores the 2016 international arbitral ruling and international law, while engaging in coercive actions like water cannons and boat rammings against Philippines vessels.
Right-leaning coverage: Right-leaning and U.S. policy sources stress the importance of strengthening the U.S.-Philippines alliance and enhancing deterrence against Beijing's coercive tactics. They advocate for modernizing Philippine defense capabilities, deepening U.S. military engagement, and maintaining freedom of navigation operations, while warning that a weak code could undermine international law.
Limits of this briefing
Coverage reflects primarily Western, Philippine, and regional perspectives. Direct statements from China's perspective on the negotiations are limited in recent sources, with most reporting coming through third parties.
Sources
- Al Jazeera: ASEAN, China fall short of agreeing on South China Sea code Centre
- CNBC: The South China Sea is proving too much for Asia's leaders to resolve Centre
- East Asia Forum: Drifting through dispute in the South China Sea Centre
- The Southeast Asia Desk: ASEAN Misses 2026 South China Sea Code Deadline Centre
- Council on Foreign Relations: China's Maritime Disputes Right