ASEAN, China fail to finalize South China Sea code after 24 years
ASEAN and China concluded meetings in Manila this week without finalizing a long-delayed code of conduct for the South China Sea. Despite reaching provisional agreement on about 80 percent of the draft, negotiators remain divided on key issues including whether the agreement would be legally binding, what geographic areas it covers, and how it relates to international law. The code has been under negotiation for over two decades and covers disputed waters claimed by China and contested by the Philippines, Vietnam, Brunei, and Malaysia. Beyond diplomatic talks, tensions persist at sea, with China and the Philippines experiencing multiple maritime confrontations in 2026. ASEAN expects negotiations to continue under Singapore's chairmanship in 2027. The South China Sea is strategically important as a major global trade route and potential source of natural resources. Progress has been complicated by divisions within ASEAN itself, with some members having stronger economic ties to China than others.
Key facts
- ASEAN and China reached provisional agreement on approximately 80% of a draft code of conduct in November 2026
- Negotiations have continued for over 20 years, beginning in 2002 with a non-binding declaration
- China claims sovereignty over most of the South China Sea, overlapping exclusive economic zones of Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, and Vietnam
- A 2016 international arbitration tribunal ruled against China's nine-dash line claim, but Beijing rejected the ruling
- Unresolved issues include whether the code will be legally binding, geographic scope, and how it relates to international law
- The South China Sea facilitates over three trillion dollars in annual ship-borne commerce
- Maritime confrontations between China and the Philippines increased significantly from 2022 onward, with incidents in 2024, 2025, and 2026
- Cambodia and Laos, which have no direct territorial claims, have generally favored less restrictive provisions in negotiations
- Singapore will chair ASEAN in 2027 and inherit negotiations expected to continue into next year
- The Philippines, as 2026 ASEAN chair, conducted nine rounds of talks and two senior officials' meetings but failed to conclude negotiations as targeted
How different outlets framed it
Left-leaning coverage: Left-leaning outlets focus on China's aggressive actions as the primary obstacle, criticizing Beijing's refusal to accept international law and the 2016 arbitration ruling against its claims. They emphasize Chinese coercion tactics against the Philippines—water cannons, coast guard harassment, and military buildups—and frame US-Philippines alliance strengthening as a necessary response to Chinese assertiveness. Western outlets highlight the need for US commitment to defending the Philippines and preventing Chinese hegemony in the region.
Right-leaning coverage: Right-leaning perspectives emphasize Chinese sovereignty claims and concerns about foreign interference in regional disputes. They present China's position that the South China Sea should be managed by regional states without US involvement, frame Western pressure for binding agreements as neo-imperialist interference, and argue that ASEAN states should negotiate directly with Beijing. Some conservative outlets suggest China's assertiveness is justified as responses to Philippine provocations.
Limits of this briefing
Coverage reflects primarily Western, Philippine, and Southeast Asian perspectives; Chinese state media views are less represented in English-language sources. The analysis relies heavily on recent 2026 reporting, though long-term trends inform context. Some technical details about negotiation positions come from analyst commentary rather than direct government statements.
Sources
- Al Jazeera: ASEAN, China fall short of agreeing on South China Sea code Centre
- Reuters (via US News): China and Southeast Asia Pledge to Avoid Disputes During Talks on South China Sea Pact Centre
- The Epoch Times: South China Sea Code Talks Between ASEAN, China to Continue Into 2027 Right
- East Asia Forum: Drifting through dispute in the South China Sea Centre
- Radio Free Asia: South China Sea code of conduct could depend on landlocked Laos Left