Gaza ceasefire enters stalled second phase amid humanitarian crisis
Gaza's ceasefire, brokered by the Trump administration and taking effect in October 2025, has entered a critical second phase focused on Hamas disarmament, Israeli withdrawal, and Palestinian governance. However, one year into the agreement, the UN-backed Board of Peace issued a bleak assessment this week warning the ceasefire could collapse without immediate action. Palestinian health authorities report over sixteen hundred deaths and thousands injured since the truce began, while Israel maintains control of approximately sixty percent of Gaza. Only about one-third of agreed humanitarian aid deliveries have entered the territory. The peace plan envisions an international stabilization force, a new Palestinian civilian administration, and phased disarmament negotiations. Both sides have faced accusations of violations—Palestinians say Israeli military operations continue daily, while Israel accuses Hamas of refusing to disarm. Mediators from Egypt, Qatar, and Turkey continue seeking implementation of the second phase.
Key facts
- Gaza ceasefire entered phase two in January 2026 after taking effect October 10, 2025, with an international Board of Peace established to oversee implementation
- Over 1,600 Palestinians killed and 5,969 injured since ceasefire began, according to Gaza Government Media Office, with 6,233 documented Israeli violations as of November 16, 2026
- Israel controls approximately 60 percent of Gaza, exceeding the 53 percent outlined in the ceasefire agreement
- Only 33 percent of agreed daily humanitarian aid truck deliveries have entered Gaza since the ceasefire took effect
- Second phase negotiations stalled over Hamas disarmament and Israeli withdrawal timelines, with an International Stabilization Force deployment delayed
How different outlets framed it
Left-leaning coverage: Left-leaning outlets stress that Israel has systematically violated the ceasefire with over six thousand documented breaches, expanded territorial control beyond agreed limits, obstructed humanitarian aid, and continued daily military operations despite ceasefire terms. They frame Netanyahu's statements about maintaining military presence as rejecting genuine peace and extending Palestinian suffering.
Right-leaning coverage: Right-leaning coverage emphasizes Israel's security concerns about Hamas disarmament, noting that Gaza has remained a threat and questioning whether a phased approach can succeed. Sources cite Israel's need to maintain control pending genuine demilitarization and frame Israeli military actions as responses to Hamas violations and security threats.
Limits of this briefing
Coverage reflects significant disagreement about ceasefire violations and their causes. Right-leaning Israeli perspectives on security justifications are less represented in available sources; most coverage comes from Palestinian, humanitarian, and international organizations. Death toll and violation figures come primarily from Palestinian sources and require independent verification.
Sources
- Associated Press / WRAL: Board of Peace delivers bleak report on Gaza, warning of ceasefire collapse without immediate action Centre
- The Intercept: Palestinians Are Trapped Between War and Peace With Ceasefire Left
- Council on Foreign Relations: A Guide to the Gaza Peace Deal Centre
- New Arab: Gaza ceasefire talks return to square one amid escalation fears Left
- Times of Israel: Board of Peace: Israel holding up Hamas disarmament; Netanyahu gov't must allow more winter supplies into Gaza Right