Zing Open Zing
Politics

ASEAN, China fail to finalize South China Sea code after 20-year push

17 November 2026 · Source balance: Centre

China and Southeast Asian nations fell short this week of finalizing a long-delayed code of conduct for the South China Sea, despite reaching tentative agreement on about eighty percent of the draft during meetings in Manila. The Philippines, as current ASEAN chair, had made concluding the code a priority, but disagreements remain on key issues including whether the agreement would be legally binding and how China's sweeping maritime claims align with international law. The South China Sea, home to half the world's merchant ships and an estimated 3.5 trillion dollars in annual trade, has seen mounting confrontations in recent years, particularly between Chinese and Philippine coast guard forces. While both sides pledged to exercise restraint, analysts describe reaching a final agreement as unlikely without major concessions. Singapore, which assumes ASEAN leadership next year, will inherit the negotiations.

Key facts

  • Negotiators reached tentative agreement on approximately 80 percent of the code of conduct draft as of November 16, 2026
  • ASEAN and China have negotiated a South China Sea code for over 20 years without concluding a final agreement
  • Half the world's merchant ships pass through the South China Sea; 2026 trade volume estimated at 3.5 trillion dollars
  • China claims sovereignty over nearly the entire South China Sea via its nine-dash line, overlapping with exclusive economic zones of Brunei, Indonesia, Malaysia, the Philippines, and Vietnam
  • A 2016 international arbitration tribunal ruled China's historic rights claims over the South China Sea have no legal basis; China rejects this ruling
  • Recent years have seen escalating maritime confrontations, particularly between Chinese coast guard vessels and Philippine resupply missions to Second Thomas Shoal
  • Key unresolved issues include whether the code will be legally binding and how to handle China's territorial claims relative to international law
  • Singapore will assume ASEAN chairmanship in 2027 and inherit ongoing code of conduct negotiations

How different outlets framed it

Left-leaning coverage: Left-leaning outlets emphasize China's perceived violations of international law, the 2016 international tribunal ruling against Chinese claims, and the Philippines' need for a rules-based maritime order. They highlight aggressive Chinese tactics like water cannoning resupply vessels and argue that stronger ASEAN unity and transparent exposure of China's actions are necessary to protect smaller nations' sovereignty and maintain regional stability.

Right-leaning coverage: Right-leaning and Chinese-perspective outlets argue that the Philippines' confrontational approach and alignment with external powers like the United States undermine ASEAN unity and regional stability. They frame Philippine actions as provocative, suggest the country is being used as a tool for great-power competition against China, and contend that Beijing's claims and military activities are proportionate responses intended to maintain peace.

Limits of this briefing

Reporting focuses primarily on official statements and high-level diplomacy; on-the-ground incidents and military perspectives from some stakeholders receive less coverage. Internal ASEAN member divisions are noted but the specific positions of Indonesia, Malaysia, and Vietnam receive limited direct sourcing in these reports.

Sources

More stories

See all latest stories